As solar power continues to grow as a key player in the energy mix, one important concept has emerged that signifies the challenges associated with high solar penetration: the saturation point. The saturation point of solar renewable electricity refers to the stage where the amount of electricity generated by solar power exceeds the demand for electricity, particularly during peak solar generation periods.
When solar capacity approaches this level, grid operators face difficulties balancing electricity supply and demand, leading to inefficiencies and financial implications. This phenomenon is closely tied to a concept known as the Duck Curve.
The Duck Curve: Understanding Its Commercial and Operational Impact
The Duck Curve is a graphical representation of power demand throughout a 24-hour period, showcasing the impact of solar energy generation on the electricity grid. Its name is derived from its distinctive shape, which resembles a duck. The curve highlights the mismatch between solar energy generation and energy demand, particularly during midday when solar generation is at its peak.
Shape of the Curve:
The Duck Curve illustrates that solar generation begins to rise during the morning, peaking during midday when solar output is at its highest. However, the demand for electricity during these hours is relatively low. As the sun sets, solar generation falls rapidly while demand typically rises, creating a steep “ramping” challenge for grid operators as non-renewable sources need to rapidly scale up to meet the demand. This results in the so-called “neck” of the duck.
Negative Pricing:
When solar generation surpasses demand during the midday, electricity prices can drop significantly, sometimes going negative. In cases of negative pricing, solar generators might actually have to pay to inject electricity into the grid due to the oversupply, or curtail production entirely, which is financially unsustainable for producers.
Over-generation Risk:
As more solar power plants come online, the grid faces over-generation risk during these periods, where there’s more electricity than can be consumed. This causes a devaluation of solar-generated electricity, diminishing returns on investment and discouraging further solar development unless paired with energy storage or consumption-shifting mechanisms.
Addressing the Duck Curve: Storage and Consumption Shifting Solutions
As solar continues to penetrate deeper into the energy market, solutions must be found to mitigate the saturation point and prevent the negative economic impacts of over-generation. Here are some key methods to capture and shift solar generation to align better with demand:
Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS)
How It Works: Batteries store excess solar electricity generated during the day for use during periods of higher demand, such as the evening when solar generation is no longer available. Lithium-ion batteries are the most commonly used storage technology due to their energy density and falling costs.
Commercial Implications: Batteries help flatten the Duck Curve by smoothing out the supply of electricity, making it possible to store energy during midday and dispatch it during the evening. This allows solar plants to retain more value and avoid the financial losses associated with curtailment or negative pricing.
Virtual Power Plants (VPP)
How It Works: A Virtual Power Plant is a network of decentralized energy resources (like rooftop solar, batteries, electric vehicles) that are aggregated and managed through software to act as a single, dispatchable power source. VPPs optimize when and where to deploy stored solar energy to the grid based on demand and pricing signals.
Commercial Implications: VPPs can monetize energy flexibility, allowing solar producers to participate in grid services like frequency regulation, demand response, and peak shaving. This enhances the value of distributed solar assets and reduces reliance on traditional fossil fuel plants for grid stability.
Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging
How It Works: EVs can act as both a load and storage for excess solar energy. During the day, EVs can be charged using surplus solar power, thus increasing electricity demand when solar production is high. Some advanced systems can also discharge stored energy back to the grid during peak demand periods.
Commercial Implications: Incentivizing EV charging during midday solar peaks can absorb excess electricity and prevent grid overloads. The ability to use EVs as mobile batteries could also help to smooth out the Duck Curve and increase the utility of solar generation.
Heat Pumps
How It Works: Heat pumps are a highly efficient way to use electricity for heating and cooling. By running heat pumps during the day, excess solar energy can be converted into thermal energy (e.g., stored in a water tank or building structure), thereby shifting consumption from evening peaks.
Commercial Implications: Similar to EV charging, incentivizing the use of heat pumps during periods of solar over-generation can create a flexible demand resource that helps align generation with consumption patterns.
Hot Water Storage
How It Works: Excess solar power can be used to heat water, which can then be stored in insulated tanks and used later when there is no solar energy available. This is particularly effective in residential and commercial buildings, where hot water demand is relatively steady.
Commercial Implications: Hot water storage is a low-cost, low-tech solution for load shifting, offering an effective way to consume excess solar power and reduce the pressure on the grid during peak generation times. Utilities could offer incentives to encourage consumers to adopt such systems.
Conclusion: The Path Forward
The Duck Curve underscores the operational and financial challenges that come with high solar penetration. As we approach the saturation point of solar energy on the grid, the need for flexible solutions that balance supply and demand becomes paramount. Battery storage, VPPs, and load-shifting technologies such as EV charging, heat pumps, and hot water storage offer promising avenues to manage these challenges. These technologies not only help solar generators capture more value but also support grid stability, ensuring that solar can continue to grow as a major renewable energy source without undermining the integrity of the electricity network.
In the future, a combination of innovative policies, market structures, and technological advancements will be key to managing the Duck Curve and unlocking the full potential of solar energy in a sustainable and economically viable manner.
References
US Energy Information Administration, June 21, 2023, ‘As solar capacity grows, duck curves are getting deeper in California’. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=56880&src=email
Also, check out the YouTube channel ‘Gary Does Solar’, particularly the video on Duck Curves, ‘The Future of Solar Energy Exporting’.
While You Are Here…
Why not use one or all of Bryce Energy Services free online calculators.
Carbon Footprint — Solar Panels — Electric Chargers — ISO 50001 Gap Analysis
Blog News Carbon Footprint
The Carbon Cost of Building the Future: Why Capital Projects Need Their Own Carbon Accounts
Across the UK, enormous amounts of capital are being invested in new infrastructure. Electricity networks [...]
Oct
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Carbon Accounting Without Adding Another Job to the Business
For many businesses, the biggest barrier to carbon reporting is not necessarily the calculation itself. [...]
Sep
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Your Carbon Footprint Is Only as Good as the Data Your Suppliers Give You
For many businesses, calculating Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions is relatively straightforward. You can [...]
Sep
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Stop Measuring Carbon in Isolation: Use the Metrics That Already Run Your Business
Most businesses understand the basic idea of carbon reporting: Measure emissions this year. Measure them [...]
Aug
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Net Zero to 2050: Perhaps the Carbon Plan Should Become the Business Plan
For many businesses, 2050 feels a very long way away. Most organisations rarely plan in [...]
Aug
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Climate Change Has Not Gone Away Because a Council Votes to Stop Calling It an Emergency
There can hardly be a worse time for councils to start reversing climate emergency declarations. [...]
Aug
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Your Profit and Loss Account Is Not a Carbon Footprint
Carbon accounting is becoming increasingly important to businesses of every size. Customers are requesting emissions [...]
Aug
Blog News Sustainability
A Billion Plastic Pellets on Our Doorstep — Where Is the Urgency?
A significant environmental incident is unfolding on the beaches of North East England, yet beyond [...]
Jul
Blog News Carbon Footprint
Net Zero Airports? We Need to Talk About Facilitated Emissions
Airports are increasingly publishing impressive carbon-reduction claims. “Airport emissions reduced by 50%.” “Carbon-neutral operations.” “Net [...]
Jul
Measure - Manage - Reduce - Offset - Report
Bryce Energy Services combines practical energy and carbon consultancy with the CO₂ Impact online platform, helping businesses measure their emissions, meet reporting requirements and turn carbon data into achievable reduction projects.
With CO₂ Impact, your business can:
Unlike a standalone carbon calculator, we can help you interpret the results, investigate energy-saving opportunities and prioritise projects based on cost, carbon savings and practical deliverability.
CO₂ Impact subscriptions start from £29 per month.